Local SEO

SEO Competitor Analysis: How to Do It in 6 Steps (Free)

Find your real organic competitors, compare 7 things side by side and turn the gaps into a short action list. Free tools, one afternoon.

By the Organic Climb teamNov 19, 20265 min read

Short answerAn SEO competitor analysis (also called competitive SEO analysis) means looking at the businesses that show up above you on Google, then figuring out why. Which searches they rank for, which pages they have that you don’t, who links to them, and how their Google Business Profile beats yours. For a small business it takes an afternoon and free tools. The goal isn’t to copy them. It’s to find the 3–5 gaps you can close first.

Most owners already know who their competitors are in real life. Your SEO competitors are often different people. The plumber across town you’ve never met might be the one who shows up first every time someone nearby searches “water heater repair”. That’s who you’re really up against.

Who are your SEO competitors (organic competitors)?

Your organic competitors are the sites that rank on Google for the searches your customers use. Not the ones with the biggest ads or the most trucks. To find them:

  1. Write down your 5 most important searches. Your main service plus your city: “roof repair Austin”, “dog grooming Fort Wayne”. Not sure which ones? Start with our guide to SEO keywords.
  2. Google each one in a private window. It hides your own history, so results are closer to what a customer sees.
  3. Write down who appears in the map pack and the first 5 regular results. Skip Yelp, Angi and other directories for now.
  4. Count who shows up most often. The 3 names that appear again and again are your real SEO competitors.

What to compare: a simple checklist

Open each competitor’s site and Google listing next to yours, and fill in a table like this:

What to check Where to look What it tells you
Google reviews Google Maps How far behind you are on Maps
Primary category Under the name on their listing Which category Google trusts for that search
Service pages Their menu Services they have a page for and you don’t
Page titles The blue headline in Google results Which words they target
Area pages “Areas we serve” or city pages Towns they rank in and you don’t
Backlinks A free backlink checker Local sites that mention them
Blog or guides Their blog Questions they answer that bring traffic

You don’t need every row to be perfect. You’re looking for patterns. If all three competitors have a separate page for “drain cleaning” and you mention it in one line on your homepage, that’s your first gap.

Free website check. Send us your site and we’ll reply within 24 hours on business days with what is holding it back on Google. No obligation. Get a free mini-audit →

How to do an SEO competitor analysis in 6 steps

1. Compare Google Business Profiles first

For local businesses, this is where most of the difference is. Look at review count and how recent the reviews are, the primary category, photos, hours and whether they reply to reviews. If they have 140 reviews and you have 9, no website tweak will close that gap. A steady habit of asking will. (Our free review link generator makes the asking easy.)

2. List the pages they have and you don’t

Go through their menu and write down every service and area page. Then do the same for your site. Each page they have and you don’t is a search they can rank for and you mostly can’t.

3. Look at their titles and headings

Google each competitor’s name and read the blue headline under their site. That’s their page title, and it usually holds the main keyword they’re going after. Compare it with yours. If theirs says “Emergency Plumber in Tulsa, OK” and yours says “Home”, you’ve found something to fix in five minutes.

4. Check who links to them

Free backlink checkers from tools like Ahrefs show a sample of the sites linking to any domain. Ignore the spammy ones. Look for local ones: the chamber of commerce, a local news story, a supplier, a sponsorship page. Those are links you can often get too.

5. Find the questions they answer

If a competitor has a blog, look at its most useful posts. “How much does a new roof cost in Boise” or “Why is my AC freezing up” bring people who later need the service. You can write a clearer, more honest answer.

6. Turn it into a short action list

Don’t try to fix everything. Pick 3–5 gaps, roughly in this order:

  • Google Business Profile: category, photos, reviews.
  • Missing service pages for your money services.
  • Page titles and headings that don’t say what you do and where.
  • Missing area pages for towns you actually serve.
  • Local links and mentions.
Rather have someone do it? Our SEO competitor analysis service covers 3 competitors and ends with a short report and a prioritized action list.

Free tools that are enough for a small business

  • Google itself and a private browser window: for who ranks and what their titles say.
  • Google Maps: for reviews, categories and photos.
  • Google Search Console: for the searches you already show up for. Compare them with what your competitors rank for.
  • Free versions of Ahrefs or Semrush: limited, but enough to peek at a competitor’s top pages and links.

Paid tools help when you’re comparing hundreds of keywords. For a local business with 3 competitors, they’re nice to have, not a must.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Copying their text. Duplicate content won’t help you rank, and it can look bad to customers who compare.
  • Chasing a national brand. If Home Depot ranks for “fence installation”, that’s not your competitor. The local fence company in position 3 is.
  • Only checking once. Look again every few months. Competitors add pages and reviews too.
  • Doing everything at once. Three gaps closed this month beat fifteen half-done.

Quick questions

What’s the difference between competitive SEO analysis and competitor analysis?

People use them for the same thing: studying the sites that rank above you to find what to improve. “Competitive analysis” sometimes covers prices and marketing too. For SEO, focus on rankings, pages, links and your Google listing.

How many competitors should I analyze?

Three is enough for most local businesses. More than five and the patterns get blurry.

What should an SEO competitor analysis report include?

Good competitor analysis SEO reports cover the same few things: who your competitors are and for which searches, a side-by-side table like the one above, and a short list of actions in priority order. If a report doesn’t end with “do these 3 things first”, it’s not finished.

How long until it pays off?

Fixes to your Google profile and page titles can show up in a few weeks. New pages and links take months. Our take on what SEO costs and how long it takes goes deeper.

Related reading: What are SEO keywords? · Why your business isn’t showing on Google Maps · What is local SEO?

Our promise

Your website stays yours. After our training, you edit it yourself

We build and fix everything by the rules, with no hacks or hidden code. Then we train you in the admin, so you can update texts, prices and photos without waiting for a developer.

How it works →
  • Clean, standard setup, no hidden code
  • Training: we show you the admin step by step
  • All logins and files stay in your name
Written by the Organic Climb team

SEO specialists, developers and copywriters who audit, fix and grow small business websites. Every article is written by a person, checked for AI (under 10%) and updated when Google changes something. Last updated November 19, 2026.

Contact

Need help with your SEO?

We work in writing: fast, clear and easy to come back to. Reply within 24 hours on business days.

hello.organicclimb@gmail.com

Message us